patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Cloth Diapers: Are They Worth It?

This weekend, as thousands of babies and caregivers attempted to break a world record for simultaneous changing of cloth diapers, including a group in Mt. Airy, I reevaluated my decision to use cloth diapers. (The results of whether they made the record or not are not yet out)

I made my decision based on my desire to be a good environmentally conscious citizen and economics.

My instinct told me that cloth diapers would be both more economical and better for the environment. They would also mean fewer chemicals near my son’s skin.

It turns out that washing, sanitizing and, in general, dealing with cloth diapers is a drain on the environment. Most diaper services use harsh chemicals to be certain that diapers are clean.

I ended up choosing G Diapers, which are a bit of a hybrid. G Diapers have a knit outer shell with a plastic snap-in liner. Inside the snap-in liner you can either put in a cloth insert or a disposable one. The disposable insert is biodegradeable and flushable, although I have not trusted my plumbing enough to try that. We have, however, tried composting the disposable liners that only have urine, to the general disgust of many of my family members.

A year and four sizes (newborn, small, medium and large) later, I feel like I made the right choice for the environment, but likely the wrong choice for my lifestyle. I may have saved some money, but the time I have lost was worth more than the money. Staying on top of diaper laundry, which, obviously, is not washed with anything else, is a huge chore, especially with a full-time job outside the home. And although, I can change a diaper pretty quickly at this point, it still is more time consuming to load these diapers than it is to pull out a disposable diaper.

If we have another baby, then I will have saved more money and more resources, and I will use my G Diapers again, but if I had it to do all over again, knowing what I know now, I would choose disposable diapers.

If you're interested in G Diapers, you can buy them online or locally at Wegmans or Babies R Us (Media location and Springfield location). I found the best deal was in the Babies R Us two packs or the multipacks on Amazon.com.

Patch_comments_icon

Lucy Bennett

1:54 am on Monday, April 23, 2012

What kind of diapers do you use? Are you happy with the choice you made?

Reply

Elizabeth

11:14 am on Monday, April 23, 2012

I use disposable diapers. I wanted to try cloth but
my husband wanted no part of it. In the end I'm glad we used disposable. I was more attracted to economics of them. But I breastfeed and make my own baby food so the cost of diapers is justifiable.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Bob Byrne

9:06 am on Monday, April 23, 2012

I have been a single parent since two of my three kids (now teens) were in diapers. One day my kids asked me how many diapers I had changed in my life time. I came up with a very conservative estimate of just over 5,000 (including the oldest child). Their mother wanted to try going the cloth diaper route. The result: piles of unused cloth diapers that were incredibly expensive and now are used for soaking up big spills, like paint. But I think most working parents come to the same conclusion.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Bretany Pilko

1:11 pm on Tuesday, April 24, 2012

My friend is on her third child and decided to go with cloth diapers this time around. She uses a service that picks up the dirty diapers and delivers clean cloth diapers each week. It sounds like a great alternative. Here is the link to the service: http://www.babyschoicediapers.com

Reply

Karen Rotwitt Perrin

12:28 am on Wednesday, April 25, 2012

I use cloth and am very happy with my choice. It definitely is a bigger upfront cost, but I haven't spent more than $100 on any and all diapering supplies since my son was born and he'll be 3 in June. I don't use a service and do all the laundry myself. Perhaps it does use more water in the cleaning process (although I've got an Eco washing machine that uses a ridiculously little amount of water) but I think that's really the least of the many evils concerning diapering. I've certainly had moments (like when I'm changing his THIRD poopy diaper in a day) when I've wished I could just toss it in the trash can and not deal, but that's just life. The benefits outweigh the hardships.

Reply

NS Citizen

2:02 pm on Wednesday, April 25, 2012

We have been using the gDiaper system for 2 1/2 years now with our 2 youngest. We have had zero issues with them. We use the cloth inserts during the day and the flush-able inserts at night or when we go out. We are very pleased with the system and could not imagine going back to the old diapers now.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Lucy Bennett

10:42 pm on Wednesday, April 25, 2012

Have you found a way to avoid the leakage issues? I double up on the cloth inserts at night, but in the morning, I frequently find that my son has wet through his pajamas.

Drea Lamson

10:25 am on Thursday, April 26, 2012

We chose cloth diapers for both of our children. When my husband and I examined the facts behind cloth vs. landfill diapers, the choice was more than clear. We wash at home.. this just takes minutes every other day or two. ***The manufacture and use of disposable diapers amounts to 2.3 times more water wasted than cloth (SEE http://www.realdiaperassociation.org/diaperfacts.php).*** The amount of water used to clean cloth diapers in equivalent to having a potty trained child in the home.
Why else did we choose cloth?....
Cost: The average parent will spend $2,000-$3,000 to diaper just one child in disposables. A newborn will go through approximately 100 diapers per week. An older tot uses about 50-60 diapers per week. With stats stating 1 in 3 families are struggling to provide diapers for their children, these numbers are no laughing matter.
The average cost to diaper in cloth? Approximately $100-$800 (depending on brand and system choice) from birth to potty training! Cloth diapers can save the average family THOUSANDS. When buying gently used the price drops dramatically, as does the impact to our Earth. Cloth dipes can often be reused on multiple children. Many families can then resell gently loved fluff and regain up to 60% of their expense. You can’t say that about a disposable!
to be cont..

Reply

Drea Lamson

10:25 am on Thursday, April 26, 2012

Cont..
Environment: The 7,500 to 9,500 disposable diapers a child uses between birth and potty training don’t just disappear. This adds up to 1 TON of diaper waste per CHILD per year. It is the top contributor to household waste and takes up to 500 years to decompose. Tons of wood, petroleum, water and chlorine are used for production of “disposables”. Out of sight, out of mind may be convenient for the moment; ultimately, we all suffer the collective consequence. The end result? Our landfills will be entirely overflowed, our soil and water saturated with toxic chemicals, and our Earth irreversibly polluted.

Health: Disposables can contain dioxin (a carcinogen), sodium polyacrylate (found to cause toxic shock syndrome when FORMERLY used in tampons), and Tributyl-tin (TBT) (a hormonal causing pollutant). Not a pretty concoction to stick on delicate baby 24/7. Cloth diapers are made of natural fibers. What parent wouldn’t feel great having cotton, hemp, or bamboo wrapped around their precious bundle? Independent studies have shown the skyrocketing increase in diaper rash over past decades. In 1955 prevalence was at 7% and by 1991 up to 78%!! (http://www.diaperpin.com/clothdiapers/article_diaperdrama2.asp)

Reply

TParker

10:25 am on Thursday, April 26, 2012

I use cloth and I think it's great. I don't find it time consuming at all and no I am not a stay at home mom. I think it is super easy. I use a Miele HE washer set on the regular cycle so I don't believe its using that much extra water or energy to run 2 extra loads a week. I didn't even notice an increase in our water or electric bill. I line dry everything. I used disposables for a week on vacation and will never use them again. They were so disgusting. The smell terrible even straight out of the box and poop always leaked out of them. I seriously don't know how people use them.

Reply

Audreylynne

12:28 pm on Thursday, April 26, 2012

I have two in cloth and i chose cloth because i couldnt imagine putting that many disposables into landfills...it made me queezy. i use ragababes, happy heinys, bum cheeks, chelory's and charlie bananas. i enjoy cloth diapering...i like how cute the diapers are. the colors and prints are seriously cute! I would save money if i found the diaper that is perfect for me but i have a feeling with as many as i have tried i havent saved $:( but it has been a fun ride! i wouldnt change it for anything!

Reply

Stacie Wilson

12:28 pm on Thursday, April 26, 2012

I work full time outside of the house and have a 40 min commute each way. I don't find diaper laundry a big deal what-so-ever. I wash every 2 days but have a stash big enough that I don't have to fold/prep them more than once or twice a week, which I do while sitting on the floor while my baby is playing. Laundry takes a total of maybe 5-10 mins, including time to hang them to dry. Diaper laundry to me is so much easier than having to worry about buying disposables. I truly believe CDing is a personal choice though and the laundry may overwhelm other working mamas. I just wanted to provide a counter arguement to the comment "Staying on top of diaper laundry, which, obviously, is not washed with anything else, is a huge chore, especially with a full-time job outside the home." :)

Reply

Erica C.

1:21 pm on Thursday, April 26, 2012

I work full time as well and have a 2 hour commute each way, so I spend about 12 hours a day (often times more) away from home. I do diaper laundry every 2-3 days (I just don't like them sitting for too long), and I don't find it to be time consuming or a pain at all. Sometimes I get mad if I forget I put a load in, and have to stay up to switch them to the dryer/hang to dry so they don't sit overnight and get stinky, but it's a small price to pay. And hey, I have a 6 month old.. I don't sleep all night anyway! :) I'm happy we chose cloth! Stuffing isn't too bad either. I do it while watching tv or just throw it in randomly while I'm cooking dinner/talking on the phone or watching the baby play!

I hope that people who are on the fence about trying read through the positive comments here, because I think it's very helpful to hear from people from both ends of the spectrum!

Reply

Joe Howard

11:14 pm on Tuesday, May 1, 2012

I think I finally get what Patch is all about. Nothing wrong with it, but a bit misleading. At least I finally know. Patch is about baby poop and diapers.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Anthony Leone

9:39 am on Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Hi Joe,

Well, to be honest with you, I've worked at newspapers, magazines and online news/opinion websites as editor, columnist and reporter for many years and all of them have run a wide variety of stories and items. And Patch is really no different.

I know that not all readers like all of the things we run. Some don't like our crime or government stories or even articles on township or school board meetings. Or even some of the blog posts.

But what type of things do you, Joe, want to see on Patch? What type of blogs or articles would you like to read about?

Or better yet, what type of blog would you like to write yourself? The readers are allowed to blog anytime they want by going to this link: http://haverford.patch.com/blog/apply

Thanks for reading and take care,
Anthony

Leave a comment